The Art of Reviewing

Panel discussion

16:30 - 17:15 Monday 11 February 2013

Confirmed panelists

Alicia Newton, Nature Geoscience

Chris Turney, Journal of Quaternary Science

Denis-Didier Rousseau, Climate of the Past

Moderator: Alberto Reyes

Session topics

- How to write a useful review (Alicia Newton)
- What makes an excellent review? Discussion of different review aspects and their helpfulness in taking editorial decisions (all panelists)
- Discussion of reviewing issues specific to young scientists (panelists and audience)
- Open questions from the floor